Black America's cultural tipping point
Janet Jackson's 40-year-old breast's coming out party is starting to look like
one of those Tipping Points, for which we hacks are always searching. Since
that extraordinary evening, a cascade of events appears to be leading to a
wide-spread, mostly voluntary, clean-up of popular culture.
And a lot of it is coming from the heart of the black community.
Consider. In mid-May, during a celebration of the 50th anniversary of the U.S.
Supreme Court's decision in Brown v. Board of Education, which ended
segregation in public schools, Bill Cosby left black leaders stone-faced.
"These people were hit in the face with rocks to get an education, and now
we've got these knuckleheads walking around," declared The Coz. "The lower
economic people are not holding up their end in this deal. These people are not
parenting ... I can't even talk the way these people talk: 'Why you ain't,'
'Where you is.' You can't be a doctor with that kind of crap coming out of your
mouth." Moving on to crime, he said, "These are not political prisoners. These
are people going around stealing Coca-Cola."
Right on, I thought, along with (apparently) Kweisi Mfume, head of the NAACP.
Then, last week, P. Diddy announced that enough was enough. He was a middle-
aged, mainstream fashion designer and Broadway star, not, after all, a bad boy
for life. A day later, Dennis Rodman popped up on a nighttime talk show to say
pretty much the same, and looking, well, normal. Still had four studs in his
mouth and nose, but he admitted that yes, they were pretty silly.
Just to reassure us that the stars were still in their heavens, however, the
Mayor of Atlanta decided, in a tone-deaf misreading of the national mood, that
June 7 was the official day of ultra- profane Atlanta-born rapper Ludacris.
Not such a good idea, it seemed, since many saw this as a reversion to the all-
too-recent bad old days. Spelman College, the grande dame of black women's
colleges, cancelled a performance by Nelly, a rapper who'd been booked to
celebrate Ludacris Day. Juan Williams, the widely respected black correspondent
for NPR and former Washington Post columnist, went on Fox News to say that
enough was enough, and that black culture had been degraded by these hip hop
madmen. And, by the way, Cosby was right.
The City of Atlanta promptly removed any reference to Ludacris Day on its Web
site, even as it stiffly pointed out that Ludacris donated lots of money to
inner city children and was a great Atlanta man, etc., etc. Fox News host Bill
O'Reilly rejoined that Atlanta earned a billion dollars a year from hip hop-
related business and could there be a connection to the fact that Atlanta's
violent crime is four times the national average, property crime three times
the national average and murder six times the national average?
Is this shaping up to be a scrap or what?
Before I could draw breath, on Saturday night, comedian Chris Rock, no stranger
to profanity or vulgarity himself, debuted a new, cleaned up comedy show by
saying what everyone thinks, which is that Michael Jackson should and must go
to jail.
As a result of Janet Jackson's Superbowl "wardrobe malfunction," Congress
passed the Broadcast Decency Enforcement Act of 2004, and fines for indecency
jumped from $27,500 to $275,000. The radio chain Clear Channel has recently
been fined $2-million for a variety of infractions, some involving well-known
shock jock Howard Stern.
The result has been a distinct and voluntary chilling. The exposure of an
elderly woman's breast on ER was blocked, and Britney Spears, Fountains of
Wayne and Alanis Morissette have all been asked by MTV to clean up their music
videos. The chilling is not confined to low and middle-brow culture. Recently,
a cleaned-up episode of the much-praised British police drama, Prime Suspect
was aired.
Like most reasonable people, I think "indecency" should be left to premium
cable. But this stepped up government regulation is a fearsome thing (except
child porn which should be outlawed for all eternity). One can only wish the
leaders of the black community had spoken up earlier, before the Broadcast
Decency Enforcement Act, before Michael Jackson had sleepovers with another
dozen little boys, and before we had to look at that 40-year-old breast on
Superbowl Sunday, after church, with our grandkids.